2009 Schedule
| Away | Home | Score |
| Kickoff Classic |
AIFA All-Stars | Harrisburg | 26-46 |
| Week 1 |
Carolina | Florence | 37-29 | 2800 |
| Week 2 |
| D.C. | Reading | 28-51 | 4508 |
| Erie | Baltimore | 32-60 | ---- |
| Columbus | Carolina | 50-49 | 3000 |
Harrisburg | Florence | 13-19 | ---- |
| Week 3 |
| Reading | Baltimore | 44-59 | ---- |
| Fayetteville | South Carolina | 39-18 | 4004 |
Carolina | Columbus | 37-68 | 2231 |
Wyoming | Utah Valley | 62-34 | 3127 |
| New Mexico | Ogden | 42-37 | 1216 |
| Week 4 |
| South Carolina | Reading | 27-47 | 4504 |
| D.C. | Erie | 34-30 | 2500 |
| Baltimore | Harrisburg | 34-37 | 3915 |
Carolina | Fayetteville | 32-57 | ---- |
Columbus | Florence | 36-55 | ---- |
Wyoming | Ogden | 58-43 | 1500 |
| New Mexico | Utah Valley | 34-55 | 1347 |
| Week 5 |
| Erie | Carolina | 12-38 | 1500 |
| Fayetteville | Florence | 49-50 | ---- |
| Baltimore | Columbus | 19-82 | ---- |
Reading | D.C. | 39-19 | ---- |
South Carolina | Harrisburg | 40-37 | ---- |
Ogden | Wyoming | 33-77 | 3423 |
| Utah Valley | New Mexico | 58-54 | 1500 |
| Week 6 |
Erie | Reading | 13-47 | 3005 |
| Fayetteville | D.C. | 58-19 | ---- |
| Columbus | Harrisburg | 35-33 | ---- |
Florence | South Carolina | 63-59 | 2241 |
New Mexico | Wyoming | 34-56 | 3277 |
| Utah Valley | Ogden | 57-41 | 1000 |
| Week 7 |
| Baltimore | Reading | 40-36 | 3505 |
| Harrisburg | Erie | 34-31 | 1100 |
| D.C. | Columbus | 6-76 | 5035 |
South Carolina | Fayetteville | 53-48 | ---- |
| Ogden | Utah Valley | 17-55 | 2160 |
| Florence | Carolina | 37-31(OT) | 1500 |
Wyoming | New Mexico | 58-16 | 1000 |
| Week 8 |
| Reading | Erie | 66-48 | 550 |
| Florence | Baltimore | 58-52 | ---- |
| Harrisburg | D.C. | 26-44 | ---- |
Columbus | Fayetteville | 37-41 | ---- |
| Carolina | South Carolina | 27-37 | 2240 |
Ogden | Wyoming | 31-70 | 3188 |
| New Mexico | Utah Valley | 26-62 | 1413 |
| Week 9 |
| Reading | Florence | 66-55 | ---- |
| Baltimore | Harrisburg | 37-27 | ---- |
| Erie | Fayetteville | 28-58 | ---- |
D.C. | Carolina | 20-28 | ---- |
| South Carolina | Columbus | 33-54 | ---- |
Wyoming | Utah Valley | 37-43 | 1663 |
| Week 10 |
| Fayetteville | Reading | 63-50 | 3101 |
| Baltimore | Erie | 50-53 | 550 |
| D.C. | Harrisburg | 18-20 | ---- |
Columbus | South Carolina | 52-49 | ---- |
Utah Valley | Wyoming | 28-45 | 3014 |
| Ogden | New Mexico | 51-49 | 1200 |
| Week 11 |
| Harrisburg | Reading | 6-44 | 2985 |
| Carolina | Florence | 56-21 | ---- |
Wyoming | Ogden | 74-26 | 700 |
| Utah Valley | New Mexico | 57-34 | 1500 |
| Week 12 |
| Reading | D.C. | 51-35 | 1238 |
| Harrisburg | Erie | 44-54 | 500 |
Columbus | Baltimore | 32-52 | ---- |
| Fayetteville | South Carolina | 45-34 | 1581 |
| New Mexico | Ogden | 45-48 | 1200 |
| Week 13 |
| Reading | Fayetteville | 53-57 | ---- |
| D.C. | Baltimore | 25-57 | ---- |
South Carolina | Carolina | 50-36 | ---- |
| Erie | Harrisburg | 23-56 | ---- |
| Florence | Columbus | 14-37 | ---- |
New Mexico | Wyoming | 6-85 | 2817 |
| Ogden | Utah Valley | 69-70(OT) | 1471 |
| Week 14 |
| Florence | Fayetteville | 27-59 | 3200 |
| Baltimore | D.C. | 57-28 | ---- |
Harrisburg | South Carolina | 30-36 | 1385 |
| Carolina | Erie | 51-21 | 550 |
| Ogden | New Mexico | 62-42 | 1200 |
Utah Valley | Wyoming | 32-52 | 3210 |
| Week 15 |
| Erie | Reading | 27-45 | 3107 |
| Harrisburg | Baltimore | 55-58 | ---- |
| Carolina | D.C. | 44-50 | ---- |
South Carolina | Florence | 44-16 | ---- |
| Fayetteville | Columbus | 43-61 | ---- |
Utah Valley | Ogden | 69-45 | 800 |
| Week 16 |
| Erie | D.C. | 28-47 | ---- |
| Baltimore | South Carolina | 38-62 | 1422 |
Fayetteville | Carolina | 40-45 | 2000 |
| Florence | Columbus | 12-61 | ---- |
Wyoming | New Mexico | 56-9 | 1000 |
| Week 17 |
| Reading | Harrisburg | 41-14 | 1600 |
| Florence | Erie | 20-60 | 1100 |
| D.C. | Baltimore | 22-70 | ---- |
Columbus | Fayetteville | 44-25 | ---- |
| Wyoming | Utah Valley | 44-54 | 1265 |
| South Carolina | Carolina | 35-38 | 1200 |
| New Mexico | Ogden | 34-44 | 1000 |
| Week 18 |
| Ogden | Wyoming | 10-63 | 3000 |
| Utah Valley | New Mexico | 58-21 | 500 |